Creative Living & Growing with Bren Haas

The Best Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

inside personal size pot pie

If you are lucky you will have some extra turkey from that fabulous Thanksgiving dinner or chicken from rotisserie dinner. In this post, I share my the best chicken pot pie prepared in an Air Fryer Oven Recipe. I’ve also included directions to create in a conventional oven.

Create The Chicken Pot Pie Recipe Slide Show

In this video, on my YouTube Channel, I show how easy step by step this recipe really is! You can use a conventional oven but I recommend the a Power Oven Air Fryer.

This video can be found on my Bren Haas YouTube Channel.  I love making videos almost daily so be sure to subscribe to my channel if you are a YouTube user.  Be sure to follow me on YouTube for more great videos.  Look me up – I am at Bren Haas on YouTube 

** Warning: You will find yourself baking more food just because it is easy and healthier in a Power Air Fryer Oven. 

The Best Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

In this post, I am using leftovers from our Thanksgiving turkey dinner but I have also used rotisserie chicken leftovers as well.  Both taste very similar in this yummy and easy to create pie.

Because this is a classic recipe I recommend using the print option below and add this to your recipe book.  Isn’t the cute little pie plate adorable?  I use the Anchor 6″ pie plates in my Power Oven Air Fryer because they fit PERFECT!  Don’t panic if you don’t have an Electric Air Fryer you can also use this recipe in the oven just account for the size of the plate.  I share both options in the directions below.

Ingredients Needed:

  • Chicken breast or left over turkey from Thanksgiving is perfect for this recipe.
  • Rotisserie chicken is a great meat as well.  
  • Try this recipe without meat and add potatoes instead.
  • Homemade crust is super easy but you can easily use store bought pie crust.

Chopped Onions for Saute – taste amazing in coconut oil.

The Pampered Chef Roller has been my favorite for Years!  I found them on Amazon if you are interested in getting one and don’t want to deal with a Pampered Chef Consultant.

If you don’t like too much dough or crust you can skip making the bottom crust of the pie and just pour in mixture.

Consistency of filling
Perfect Consistence for the Pot Pie Filling
Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

The Best Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

inside personal size pot pie

Enjoy this all time favorite comfort meal serving for 1 or up to 4 people.  Recipe calls for Electric Oven Air Fryer making this an  easy go to meal.

Inspired by my Oven Air Fryer or also known as Mommy’s easy bake oven! 
Note: IF you don’t have an Oven Air Fryer you can use a traditional oven.  However, I strongly recommend you purchase your own Oven Air Fryer because it is my favorite appliance EVER.  Seriously, I make everything in mine.  Consider purchasing yours using my Amazon Affiliate link on this post.  You can only bake 1 pie at a time so air fryer is perfect for 2 people.

Did I convince you yet that the Power Oven Air Fryer is for you?


Let’s Connect

I’d love to hear what you create with your turkey or chicken leftovers.  Be sure to comment on this blog post or connect on my contact page. Like this recipe? Share it with your friends on social media or email! 

Happy Easy Baking,

10 responses to “The Best Chicken Pot Pie Recipe”

  1. Joe Seattleton says:

    As Vegan this looks amazing

    • Bren Haas says:

      You got me thinking… you could use a vegan milk and potatoes instead of meat making it veggie free! Thanks for commenting.

  2. Christine D says:

    I have the original recipe from a cookbook I have and YES it’s the best and easiest to make and it tastes fabulous, my family loves it. Thank you for converting it to an air fryer recipe. I completely agree about the air fryer it’s my absolute favorite appliance and I use it on a daily basis. I also recommend a ninja one pot oven, I use the pressure cooker and then I use my air fryer and I spend a third of the time in the kitchen making dinner than I used too. Thanks again for the conversion and I will be looking out for more great conversions like this. You’ve helped me become more adventurous in the kitchen!

    • Bren Haas says:

      Thank you Christine for leaving a comment. I am looking up the ninja one pot oven now – never heard of it so I appreciate your share. I’ll try to get more recipes up for you with conversions to the air fryer oven. Where do I begin… we use it daily in my home and it does make cooking faster and not to mention a speedy cleanup!

      See you in the kitchen soon,

  3. Leslie Kolkowski says:

    Just starting to use air fryer. Loved you chicken pot pie recipe and would like to follow more of your recipes. I have no website. Where should I look for you? Thanks, Bren.

    • Bren Haas says:

      You can always find my updates on my website! BrenHaas.com
      I try to leave a personal text message via v-log or text on that page. You can view it on your mobile, tablet or PC. I hope to see you there – leave me a comment to let me know you found it!

  4. Ashley Jones says:

    These meal look delicious! Love that they only take 30 minutes to be made.

  5. Penny Cale says:

    So even in the air fryer it would take 30 minutes to cook?

    • Bren Haas says:

      Each Electric Air Fryer is different so be sure to keep an eye on the top pie crust making sure it is turning golden brown and not burning. My new Oven Air Fryer set at 350*F with the pie on the lowest rake only took 14 minutes to get golden brown. The chicken mixture is already cooked on the stove top.
      I hope this helps Penny! Thanks for commenting and let me know how it taste for you!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Bren Haas

Bren Haas

Bren Haas is the creator of GardenChat which is the first online gardening social community using social media. Her website features gardening tips and tricks, recipes, travel ideas, product reviews, and social media how-to help from her personal and unique experiences.

Facebook | Instagram | Pinterest | Twitter | YouTube

All Posts

Growing Year-Round

dome garden in winter woods
Growing Year-Round in Ohio

Tweet Me! 

All content and photographs are copyright protected. Using content including but not limited to photos, posts and text without written permission is prohibited. Pinning or sharing on social media is encouraged but please ask permission before using any content from my blog for any other reason. © 2007-2022 BrenHaas.com All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience during your visit.